September 18, 2009

Post World War II Poland and Antisemitism.

Some readers believe that Poland is innocent of any wrongdoing to Jews. That the Poles were just as much victims of World War II as the Jews were victims. The sad fact is that Antisemitism has always existed in Poland and remains a blemish on the character of every day Poles, even today. This website is an opportunity for the citizens of Radziejow to separate themselves from the antisemitism of Poland. Children of Radziejow, look around and see if there is any signs of the Jewish community that flourished in Radziejow prior to World War II. Sadly, Radziejow made a decision to erase the memory of Jews from the town.
To dispel such a fantasy world of believing that the Poles have nothing against the Jews I urge you to read below an article published in the NY Times in 2006. The article describes many similar atrocities and experiences that my father went through during the War and in Post War Poland. After reading this article I urge the children of Radziejow to ask their parents and grandparents, “Is it really true?”

“One might have thought that if anything could have cured Poland of its antisemitism, it was World War II. Polish Jews and Christians were bonded, as never before, by unimaginable suffering at the hands of a common foe. One might also have thought there’d have been pity for the Jewish survivors, most of whom had lost nearly everything: their homes, their youth, their hope, their entire families. Besides, there were so few of them left to hate: only 200,000 or so in a population of 20 million.
Instead, returning Polish Jews encountered an antisemitism of terrible fury and brutality. Small wonder, then, that nearly as soon as they set foot on Polish soil, most fled all over again. Many went westward, to a place that, oddly enough, had suddenly become an oasis of tranquillity and safety by comparison: Germany. Far from being celebrated, those Poles who had sheltered Jews during the war — and there were many — begged them to say nothing, lest their neighbors deride them as “Jew lovers,” or beat them, or break into their homes (searching for the money the Jews had surely left behind) or kill them.
Polish attitudes toward the Germans remain understandably bitter. During his trip to Poland this May, when he visited Auschwitz, the German-born Pope Benedict XVI took care to speak mostly in Italian. But as Gross reminds us, in at least one respect many Poles applauded Hitler: just as he offered a final solution to Germany’s Jewish problem, he was taking care of Poland’s, too. Nazi policies toward the Jews, the legendary underground Polish diplomat Jan Karski reported to his government-in-exile in London in 1940, formed “a sort of narrow bridge where the Germans and a large part of Polish society meet in harmony.”
It wasn’t only Karski saying so. Eyewitnesses in the Warsaw ghetto saw Poles watching approvingly or even helping out, acting as spotters as German soldiers shot Jews. Polish girls were overheard joking, “Come, look, how cutlets from Jews are frying,” as the ghetto burned. Nazi accounts of Judenjagd, or “Jew hunts,” detailed how Poles pitched in to find any stray Jews the Germans somehow managed to miss. As the deportations proceeded, and practically before the trains had left for Chelmno or Belzec or Treblinka, Poles gathered on the outskirts of towns, waiting to plunder Jewish property or move into Jewish homes. And while the Nazis killed millions of Jews, Poles killed thousands — most famously, as Gross related in “Neighbors” (2001), a book that caused an uproar in Poland, 1,600 of them in the town of Jebwabne in July 1941 — crimes little noted at the time nor since remembered in Polish history books.
With the war over, and to tumultuous applause, a thousand delegates of the Polish Peasants Party actually passed a resolution thanking Hitler for annihilating Polish Jewry and urging that those he’d missed be expelled. Indeed, the mopping up soon began. Returning to their villages and towns, Jews were routinely greeted with remarks like “So, ____? You are still alive.” Their efforts to retrieve property were futile — and, sometimes, fatal. Some Jews met their end on trains — not cattle cars this time, but passenger trains, from which they were thrown off. If the trains weren’t moving fast enough, they were beaten to death.
This is a book filled with arresting, appalling images. There’s Treblinka, September 1945: a lunar landscape pockmarked with craters, where Poles had dug thousands of holes searching for gold fillings amid the bones and ashes. Or Polish synagogues disassembled for construction projects, and Jewish cemeteries used for landfill. Or Jewish schoolchildren being harassed and Jewish artisans and professionals denied work.
With the police and courts looking the other way, Jews were murdered randomly, or in pogroms. Behind these massacres, invariably, was the old canard of Jews killing Christian children for their blood, but with a new twist: Jews now craved gentile blood not just to make matzos, supposedly, but to fortify their own emaciated selves.
In the most notorious episode, 60 years ago this month, residents of Kielce, among them policemen, soldiers and boy scouts, murdered 80 Jews. “The immense courtyard was still littered with blood-stained iron pipes, stones and clubs, which had been used to crush the skulls of Jewish men and women,” the Polish-Jewish journalist Saul Shneiderman wrote the following day. It was the largest peacetime pogrom in 20th-century Europe, Gross says. But he maintains that Kielce was nothing special: during this era, it could have taken place anywhere in Poland. Polish intellectuals, Gross notes, were mortified by what was happening in their country. Only a psychopath, one wrote, could have imagined such cruelty.
Days before the pogrom, the Polish primate, Cardinal August Hlold, had spurned Jewish entreaties to condemn Roman Catholic anti-Semitism. Afterward, he charged that by leading the effort to impose Communism on Poland — Jews were in fact prominent in the party, though hardly in control — the Jews had only themselves to blame. The point was seconded by the bishop of Kielce, who suggested that Jews had actually orchestrated the unrest to persuade Britain to hand over Palestine. It was a neat trick: being Communists and Zionists simultaneously. Only the bishop of Czestochowa condemned the killings, and was promptly reprimanded by his colleagues. One wonders how Karol Wojtyla, then a young seminarian, later Pope John Paul II, viewed this cesspool of ignorance and intolerance.
If the Church gave the Jews short shrift, the same was true of the Communists, even the Jewish ones. For them, ignoring the Jewish plight, as well as Polish complicity in wartime atrocities, offered a way to ingratiate themselves with a wary nation. Besides, what was to be done? When Polish Jewish leaders called for the Communists to do something to stop the hatred, one official had a ready rejoinder. “Do you want me to send 18 million Poles to Siberia?” he asked.
How can one explain this madness? Gross conjures up the famous remark of the former Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Shamir — that Poles suck in anti-Semitism with their mothers’ milk — only to dismiss it. “Untenable in the light of common sense or empirical evidence,” he says. So, too, Gross writes, are spurious claims of ritual murder or Jewish-Communist complicity. Instead, he argues that Poles were feeling guilty: so implicated were they in the Jewish tragedy, aiding and abetting and expropriating, that the mere sight of those wraiths returning from the camps or exile or hiding, people who knew the Poles’ dirty secrets and held title to their property, was too much to bear. So they murdered Jews or chased them away.
But Gross’s evidence, right down to an anti-Semitic revue that was staged in January 1947 near the largest Jewish cemetery on the planet, Auschwitz (a local policeman had the starring role), overwhelms his theory. Such an enormous and varied inventory of inhumanity, one that included the cruelty of children too young to have felt guilt or remorse for anything, transcends any set of historical conditions. A more likely, if less politically palatable explanation, is that through their own state-of-the-art anti-Semitism, the Germans emboldened many Poles to act upon what they had always felt. The comment from Shamir, a Polish Jew himself, may strike us as deeply offensive, simplistic, racist. But whatever Gross may believe, he buttresses Shamir more than he discredits him.
Ultimately, what’s far more important than the “why” of this story is the “that”: that a civilized nation could have descended so low, and that such behavior must be documented, remembered, discussed. This Gross does, intelligently and exhaustively. That he digresses from time to time, that his chronology can be confusing, that he repeats himself and occasionally lets his indignation get the better of him, doesn’t really matter.
Two additional waves of government-inspired anti-Semitism, in 1956-7 and 1968-9, drove out most of those Polish Jews who, despite everything, had held on. (Among them were those newlyweds; the husband later told me that on his first day in New York he felt more at home than he ever had in Poland.) Now, despite occasional anti-Jewish episodes — in May, for instance, the country’s chief rabbi was punched on a Warsaw street by someone shouting “Poland for Poles” — and widespread suspicions that Jews still run things there, Poland has become a place of necro-nostalgia. Klezmer music wafts out of Krakow’s old Jewish quarter. There’s matzo in every Polish supermarket. And in liquor stores, the faces of happy Hasidim — more than you’ll now see in a lifetime in Lublin or Bialystok — stare out from bottles of Polish kosher vodka, prized for its supposed purity. Meantime, young people with even the most tangential Jewish ties now lay proud claim to their heritage. But as Gross reminds us in this depressing, devastating and infuriating book, the luckiest Polish Jews, not just before Hitler but after, were the ones who got away.” ByDavid Margolick.

No Comments

  • One cannot change what is in a nation's collective souls.What they are born with – per Yitzhak Shamir's brilliant statement.
    Why try? It only gives staisfaction to the children of the perpetrators to see that the scars are carried by the successors of the victims.
    It is painful to see the children of the victims get victimised again by recounting the past.The world celebrates the victors, pities a bit the losers but the victims are always forgotten.Looking to the future – vigilance, strength, cunning and brute action!!

  • Well looks like generalisation of Poles vs. Jews matter is a very big problem. I'm Polish and I have some Jewish friends in US and Israel and in Poland as well.
    History of our nations is not very easy like you are showing it in your blog. That history strats in medevial times when Jews where been throwing away and murdering in all Europe insted of Poland where our King Kazimierz Wielki welcome Jews to Poland, etabilished a special privilages for them as well gave away them the land next to Krakow – the town was called Kazimierz and it became latter the Jewish quarter of Krakow. And you have to know and tell to the people too.
    My father's uncle during II World War was trying to save few Jews in Drohobycz but some Ukrainians told about theat to Germans and all of them where sent to Auschwitz. He died in Auschwitz in 1943.
    To show true picture of Polish-Jewish relationship you should also on your blog you should present also very important facts:
    1. The only territory occupied in whole Europe by nazists where was death penalty law for those who hide Jews was Polish pre war territory.
    2. Anyway the largest number of honored people in Yad Vashem as the Righteous among the Nations are Polish.
    These are FACTS and you can't dispute with facts.

    Jan Karski who is mentioned in your blog he presented during the war his reports about Jews situations (getthos and Auschwitz and other terrible places) also to US President as well to the Jewish organizations in US but they DID NOT beleive him and DID NOT even try to check it, to pay for checking it. These are also facts – so why you do not like to show them as well. Karski was Polish Jew – a very brave diplomat and secret service member.

    Just try to think about it.

Leave a Reply